AllMovie

Founded in 1513, St. Augustine's history predates the entire United States. But its age doesn't make it immune to scandal. When Athalia Lindsley was murdered in plain sight, this Florida town was forever changed. City Confidential: St. Augustine details how the local government was raided to find a suspect. Police eventually came up with county manager Alan Stanford who seemed to have both a motive and the right connections. However, those connections would prove invaluable in court as Stanford talked his way to an acquittal. A&E remembers the local history that the town would like to forget.