Accompanied by Flint, army officer Charles Avery rides to deliver a peace treaty to a once-warlike Indian chief. Flint suspects that the treaty isn't Avery's only reason for seeking out the chief. Avery: Farley Granger. Chief's Daughter: Susan Kohner. Sumpter: Chuck Connors. Adams: Ward Bond. Cullen: Bing Russell. Major Forbes: Mack Williams. Big Bear: Nico Minardos. Running Horse: Henry Brandon. Choya: Abel Fernandos.