Cast
Elijah (Segment: "Either / Or") / Elijah
Mary (Segment: "Scary Mary") / Mary
Dave (segment: "Either / Or") / Dave
Psychiatric Nurse (segment: "Either / Or")
Carter Lamb (segment: "Flicker") / Carter Lamb
Oliver (Segment: "Blood Red") / Oliver
Father Jacobs (segment: "Flicker")
(segment: "Krampus Vs Elf")
Tina (segment: "Scary Mary") / Tina
(segment: "Krampus Vs Elf")
Trick-or-Treater (segment: "Scary Mary")
Nancy (segment: "Scary Mary") / Nancy
Amy (segment: "Scary Mary")
Trick-or-Treater (segment: "Scary Mary")
Ruby (segment: "Blood Red") / Ruby
Abby (Segment: Crystal Ball) / Abby
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
Cop / Police Officer (Segment: Crystal Ball)
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
Frank (segment: "Either / Or")
Terry (segment: "Blood Red") / Terry
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
Sam (segment: "Either / Or") / Sam
Funeral Party Member (segment: "Flicker")
Jack (segment: "Flicker")
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
Derrick (segment: "Flicker")
Gordon Rose (segment: "Flicker")
Lilly (segment: "Scary Mary") / Lilly
Heather (segment: "Flicker")
Trick-or-Treater (segment: "Scary Mary")
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
The Flickerman (segment: "Flicker")
Trick-or-Treater (segment: "Scary Mary")
Anderson (segment: "Either / Or")
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
(Segment: "Petrified Boy")
Jonas (Segment: Crystal Ball)
Fortune Teller (Segment: Crystal Ball)
Ring Leader (Segment: "Petrified Boy")
(segment: "Krampus Vs Elf")
Funeral Party Member (segment: "Flicker")
Lorraine (segment: "Flicker")
Doctor Arywitz / Psychiatrist (Segment: "Either / Or")
(segment: "Krampus Vs Elf")
Gerald (segment: "Either / Or") / Gerald
Rod (segment: "Scary Mary")
