Although Annie gives Mary and Lucy the okay for a double date with Robbie (Adam LaVorgna) and his brother Rick (Lance Bass), a suspicious Eric follows the two couples. Meanwhile, Matt's depression over Shana's departure infuriates John (Chaz Lamar Shepherd) when Matt bursts into tears during a dinner with their neighbors. And Simon secretly buys cigarettes with a friend, spurring Eric to use a little psychology to get a confession. Shana: Maureen Flannigan. Nigel: David Netter. Mary: Jessica Biel.