AllMovie

A 21-year-old man named Robert (Jeremy Howard) arrives in Cleveland, claiming to be the son of Oswald Harvey (Diedrich Bader). However, Oswald can't help but notice that Robert looks a lot like his pal Lewis (Ryan Stiles). It turns out that, way back in summer tap-dance class, Lewis and Oswald both slept with Robert's mother Sherrie. Before long, the two buddies are battling over the "custody" of the grown Robert, culminating in a DNA test to determine the truth. Meanwhile, Drew (Drew Carey) learns to regret allowing the employees to publish a newsletter, especially when all of the contributors go out of their way to make him look ridiculous.