review for Chronicle of a Disappearance on AllMovie

Chronicle of a Disappearance garnered worldwide critical acclaim for its seemingly uneventful, but slyly subversive depiction of Palestinian life in Israel. Those expecting a sensational or violent account of life under occupation will not find it here. Writer/director Elia Suleiman's audacious film initially seems to be a series of unconnected, sporadically amusing vignettes of life in Nazareth and Jerusalem. Suleiman's camera is usually stationary, and he often shoots these quick snippets from a distance. Some of the segments are almost defiantly tedious, as when the owner of a tacky souvenir shop repeatedly and unsuccessfully tries to get a cheap camel statuette to stand up on the shelf. Through Suleiman's meticulous camera placement and clever choice of subjects, an outsider's moving vision of a lost people -- a people in stasis -- gradually comes into focus. Suleiman's own appearances in the film in two extended set pieces exemplify the work's laconically amusing style and subversive power. In the first, he's introduced to an indifferent audience to explain his filmmaking methodology. A baby in the crowd starts crying. A chorus of cell phones rings. Every time Suleiman starts to speak, feedback wails, and a technician runs up to fiddle with the microphone. The room is soon filled with noise. In a later, more politically direct scene, Suleiman's home is invaded by Israeli policemen, who charge through, presumably looking for him, or for the police radio he's found. But as they move through his home with military precision, they don't acknowledge him standing right in front of them. Later, he listens on the radio as they inventory his home and deride him as "an airhead" and "an intellectual." In his fragmented, personal, self-critical, and low-key way, Suleiman makes his point that the disappearance he's chronicling is that of the identity of his people.