review for 2 Days in the Valley on AllMovie

2 Days in the Valley (1996)
by Karl Williams review

The feature film directorial debut of longtime TV movie creator John Herzfeld, this crime thriller interweaves several related plot lines into one tongue-in-cheek noir tapestry. The works of Quentin Tarantino clearly form the template for Herzfeld's opus, mimicking the ironic dialogue, comic violence, and sprawling multi-tiered action of Pulp Fiction (1994). The filmmaker hews a little too closely to his influences, however, resulting in a stilted, uninspired lethargy that's an indication of the film's critical lack of imagination. That doesn't mean that the film's not occasionally fun, or that genre fans won't appreciate its hip, self-mocking energy. There are some good performances too, notably from James Spader, returning to his roots as a slick, ice-cold heavy, newcomer Charlize Theron in a hilarious over-the-top sexpot role, and Paul Mazursky, who usually comes off as too precious, in the nicely modulated part of a suicidal pet lover. Bottom line, 2 Days in the Valley (1996) is a B-list rip-off, lacking in the wit, style, or invention of the films it's imitating. That said, it's not a complete wash, its competent production and entertaining star turns making it worth a look. Keep in mind, however, that others who trod in Herzfeld's footsteps would do far superior variations on Tarantino themes, such as writer/director P.T. Anderson and his superb Boogie Nights (1997) only one year later.