Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences
| Nominated |
Best Adapted Screenplay Prince of the City |
1981 |
| Nominated |
Best Director The Verdict |
1982 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Network |
1976 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Dog Day Afternoon |
1975 |
| Nominated |
Best Director 12 Angry Men |
1957 |
British Academy of Film and Television Arts
| Nominated |
Best British Film The Deadly Affair |
1967 |
| Nominated |
Best British Film The Hill |
1965 |
| Nominated |
Best Film - Any Source The Hill |
1965 |
| Nominated |
Best Film - Any Source 12 Angry Men |
1957 |
| Nominated |
Best Picture Network |
1977 |
| Nominated |
Best Picture Dog Day Afternoon |
1975 |
| Nominated |
Best Picture Murder on the Orient Express |
1974 |
Broadcast Film Critics Association
| Nominated |
Best Director Before the Devil Knows You're Dead |
2007 |
Directors Guild of America
| Nominated |
Best Director Network |
1976 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Dog Day Afternoon |
1975 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Murder on the Orient Express |
1974 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Serpico |
1973 |
| Nominated |
Best Director The Pawnbroker |
1965 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Long Day's Journey into Night |
1962 |
| Nominated |
Best Director 12 Angry Men |
1957 |
Golden Satellite Award
| Nominated |
Best Director Before the Devil Knows You're Dead |
2007 |
Hollywood Foreign Press Association
| Nominated |
Best Director Running on Empty |
1988 |
| Nominated |
Best Director The Verdict |
1982 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Prince of the City |
1981 |
| Won |
Best Director Pipe Dreams |
1976 |
| Nominated |
Best Director Dog Day Afternoon |
1975 |
| Nominated |
Best Director 12 Angry Men |
1957 |
Los Angeles Film Critics Association
| Won |
Best Director Network |
1976 |
| Won |
Best Director Dog Day Afternoon |
1975 |
| Won |
Career Achievement Award |
2007 |
National Board of Review
| Won |
Best Director The Verdict |
1982 |
New York Film Critics Circle
| Won |
Best Director Prince of the City |
1981 |
| Won |
Lifetime Achievement |
2007 |
Venice International Film Festival
| Nominated |
Film Presented Lovin' Molly |
1976 |
| Nominated |
Film Presented Child's Play |
1975 |
