| Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences |
| won |
Best Actor Marty |
1955 |
| Academy of Television Arts and Sciences |
| nom |
Outstanding Guest Actor in a Drama Series ER [TV Series] |
2009 |
| British Academy of Film and Television Arts |
| won |
Best Foreign Actor Marty |
1955 |
| Hollywood Foreign Press Association |
| nom |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Miniseries or Motion Picture Made for Television A Grandpa for Christmas |
2007 |
| won |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Drama Marty |
1955 |
| Independent Spirit Awards |
| nom |
Best Supporting Actor Spike of Bensonhurst |
1988 |
| National Board of Review |
| won |
Best Actor Marty |
1955 |
| New York Film Critics Circle |
| won |
Best Actor Marty |
1955 |