Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences
| Nominated |
Best Adapted or Original Song Score Jesus Christ Superstar |
1973 |
| Won |
Best Adapted Score Thoroughly Modern Millie |
1967 |
| Won |
Best Adapted Score My Fair Lady |
1964 |
| Won |
Best Adapted Score Irma La Douce |
1963 |
| Nominated |
Best Drama or Comedy Score Elmer Gantry |
1960 |
| Nominated |
Best Musical Score Bells Are Ringing |
1960 |
| Nominated |
Best Musical Score Pepe |
1960 |
| Won |
Best Musical Score Porgy and Bess |
1959 |
| Won |
Best Musical Score Gigi |
1958 |
| Nominated |
Best Musical Score It's Always Fair Weather |
1955 |
| Nominated |
Best Musical Score Kiss Me Kate |
1953 |
| Nominated |
Best Musical Score Three Little Words |
1950 |
| Nominated |
Best Song Two for the Seesaw |
1962 |
