Emotions reach a fever pitch as Bobby stands trial for his alleged complicity in the slaying of William Hinks, the acquitted serial killer who was stalking Lindsay. Toomey: Steven Flynn. Neel: Jeremy Roberts. Eugene: Steve Harris. Caroline: Denise Dowse. Lindsay: Kelli Williams. Bobby: Dylan McDermott. Det. McGuire: Ray Abruzzo. Lucy: Marla Sokoloff.