Prosecution and defense teams prepare for the case of Bobby Donnell, who's facing trial for his role in the slaying of sociopath William Hinks, who stalked Lindsay. Toomey: Steven Flynn. Karen: Diane DiLascio. Neel: Jeremy Roberts. Judge Knapp: James Karen. Bannish: John de Lancie. Bobby: Dylan McDermott. Eugene: Steve Harris. Rebecca: Lisa Gay Hamilton. Lindsay: Kelli Williams. Bay: Jason Kravits.