AllMovie

While playing golf at his country club, Rob (Dick Van Dyke) strikes up an acquaintance with Joe Coogan (Michael Forest). Relaying this news to Laura (Mary Tyler Moore), Rob is surprised by his wife's nervous reaction. It turns out that Joe had once been Laura's boyfriend, and that she still keeps a shoebox full of poems that he'd written to her. What neither Mr. nor Mrs. Petrie realize is that Laura's old flame is now a priest!