Part 1 of two. The four detectives team up to try to find a missing girl, who disappeared during a high-school trip to Manhattan. Ethan: Matt O'Leary. Judge Garrett: Colm Meaney. Elise: Lucinda Jenney. Faith Yancy: Geneva Carr. Leeann London: Kathleen McNenny. Eunice Peterson: Oni Faida Lampley. Logan: Chris Noth. Goren: Vincent D'Onofrio.