While planning Haley's baptism with Jack, Annabeth prosecutes a woman (Allison Smith) whose mental state seems questionable: She claims God told her to brutally stab her husband three times in the back with a butcher knife. Elsewhere, a flirtatious police officer (Dwayne Adway) asks for Maureen's help with a case he deems a justifiable homicide. However, upon further investigation, she discovers that isn't exactly true. Danny: Conor Dubin. Marla Dodds: Annie Potts. Pastor Rayburn: Kevin Rahm.