Austin Film Critics
| Won |
Best Breakthrough Artist Juno |
2007 |
| Won |
Best Breakthrough Artist Superbad |
2007 |
British Academy of Film and Television Arts
| Nominated |
Orange Rising Star Award |
2008 |
Broadcast Film Critics Association
| Nominated |
Best Young Actor Juno |
2007 |
| Nominated |
Best Young Actor Superbad |
2007 |
Chicago Film Critics Association
| Won |
Most Promising Performer Juno |
2007 |
| Won |
Most Promising Performer Superbad |
2007 |
Detroit Film Critics Society
| Nominated |
Best Newcomer Juno |
2007 |
| Nominated |
Best Newcomer Superbad |
2007 |
